A Study in Charlotte
Author: Brittany Cavallaro
Release Date: March 1, 2016
Publisher: Katherine Tegen Books
Get it here: Amazon | Barnes & Noble | Book Depository
Then a Sherringford student dies under suspicious circumstances ripped straight from the most terrifying of the Holmes stories, and Jamie and Charlotte become the prime suspects. Convinced they’re being framed, they must race against the police to conduct their own investigation. As danger mounts, it becomes clear that nowhere is safe and the only people they can trust are each other.
Equal parts tender, thrilling, and hilarious, A Study in Charlotte is the first in a trilogy brimming with wit and edge-of-the-seat suspense.
I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. Thanks Harper Collins and Edelweiss!
Sherlock Holmes and his partner-in-crime is prety ubiquitous in today’s society. Let’s not even account the number of English teachers that assign Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s works for their students. There has been numerous movies based upon this popular detective, as well as TV shows that bring them to the modern times (*laments about Sherlock Season 4*). Why is it not surprising that I picked up a Young Adult book focusing on the descendants of Watson and Holmes?
Although I immensely enjoyed the thriller aspects of the book and the mystery on who framed Holmes and Watson (as they call each other (unintentional roleplay?)), the characters are what made the book. Both Jamie and Charlotte are very reminiscent of their respective ancestors while at the same time having their own personality. There are very much Sherlock-qualities in Charlotte, but she is definitely her own person, and the same goes for Jamie.
It’s really interesting to see how a family of Holmes would behave, and when we learn of Charlotte’s family it’s equal parts amusing and a little sad. The book is told from Watson’s point of view and we can really see his admiration for Charlotte and her detective abilities. The dialogue had me grinning and laughing until 4 am in the morning. No joke – I made the mistake of starting such a captivating book late at night and I couldn’t put it down.
“‘I have to wait until the school day is over to investigate. Two hours!’ she said. ‘Do you think, if I set fire to the maths building-‘
‘No.’
‘But-‘
‘Still no.'”
The character development going on in this story was wonderfully written, and gahh I can’t express how much I loved Jamie and Charlotte! Both characters grew throughout the investigation and their interactions with each other. Alongside them were a cast of riveting secondary characters including *gasp* descendants of Moriarty! The whole gang’s here, guys.
Overall A Study in Charlotte was exactly the book I had hoped for and more. Brilliant and dynamic characters embroiled in a mysterious scheme with superb references to the original Sherlock Holmes – in other words,
Great review ! As a HUGE Sherlock fan, I can’t wait to read this myself. 😀
– Lashaan
YAY. I loveeee Sherlock too, so it’s no surprise that I enjoyed this one as much as I did!
Ahh this book sounds perfect for any Sherlock fan! I casually read/watch Sherlock…so it wouldn’t be the best book for me, but man I love that title and how it plays on A Study in Scarlet xD
Isn’t the title so cute? I mean, I’m a casual fan too, but this one is still really enjoyable 😀
I really enjoyed this books too. Besides the great character development, I liked that Cavallaro didn’t sugar coat the lives of some high school students.
That is too true, Dawn! I focused more on the mystery plot, but I have to admit, the high school aspects were well-done and realistic too.
I love the sound of this! I really like the idea of Sherlock Holmes as a woman. V. interesting.
Since Sherlock season 4 is WHO KNOWS WHEN this may have to do.
You’ll only have to wait til 2017 😀
Isn’t it? It’s kind of awesome to see Holmes’s personality in Charlotte. And Jamie as Watson is just too cute!
This would definitely be a good filler while waiting for season 4, hehe.
I’m so excited for this one–especially after having read The Hound of the Baskervilles by Arthur Conan Doyle last semester in my Detective Fiction class. Great review!
Thanks so much! Isn’t Sherlock Holmes just intriguing? I’ve read the Hound of Baskerville too, and ooohh weeee it’s a pretty swell ride. 😀
First of all, let me just say: OMG,YES.I WANT SHERLOCK BACK, DAMMIT!
Ok, now that that’s out of the way…
I had seen PR for this book but never looked into what it was about. So thank you for doing a review because, damn, this books sounds good!… And I’m not usually into the mystery book genre but now I’m definitely going to make an exception. As usual, great review! 🙂
I CAN’T WAIT FOR SEASON 4 *FLAILS*
Thanks so much Sarah! I was immediately intrigued because of the Sherlock factors and in the end really enjoyed it!
AHHH I NEED THIS BOOK. There was a good series, the Enola Holmes books, you might like (they’re MG). Also, SHERLOCK. SHERLOCK *weeps*
Definitely putting this on my TBR!
love your review! just added this book to my wish list & tbr!!! btw, love your blog! so glad i found so many amazing ones from the TP twitter chat! 🙂
This sounds absolutely amazing. I’ve always enjoyed Sherlock so I have no doubt I’d be into this. I adore a fantastic cast of characters, which ASiC seems to have. Not to mention character growth (one of my favorite things!). Lovely review, I’ll have to get my hands on this soon c:
Hehe I’m glad you enjoyed! If you liked Sherlock, I’m pretty sure you’ll have no problem falling in love with these characters too.
Eep, glad you liked it! I’m so excited about this one, especially after your review. I like that Charlotte’s her own person. Also: Sherlock season 4, right there with you! 😁
AREN’T WE ALL WAITING FOR SHERLOCK SEASON 4 THOUGH. :’D I’m excited for you to read it!!
YES! Like enough with the teasing, we get it 😂 Every time I think about season 4, I have to re-watch an episode on Netflix. And thank you! 🙂
Yasssssss!!!! I’m excited to read this one!!! I love the cover!!!! And UGH SHERLOCK WHY IS SEASON FOUR FOREVER AWAY???
RIGHT??? IT IS A CONSTANT STRUGGLE. And the cover is so apt for the book. 🙂
AILA. YES. Ah, when I saw this my heart just skipped a beat! Though I don’t have a review up for this one yet (doing it for a blog tour in March), I cannot stop praising and recommending this one. I gave this 5/5 stars, my first of 2016! Even though I’m not a fan of Sherlock (I’ve never watched the show/read the book), I still really enjoyed this one. Ah, this makes me want to reread it already!
Yayy for five stars! That’s freaking amazing. 😀 I’m so glad you enjoyed it as much as I did! YOU MUST WATCH THE SHOW THOUGH. I mean, at least ONE episode. 😉 See how you think of it!
Yippee, both you and Jenna loved this book Aila because of the characters! I’m not a big Sherlock fan, but the thriller aspects and the mystery are definitely up my alley!
Yup, the mystery was definitely super fun to read about. 😀 You don’t need to be a Sherlock fan to enjoy this one, too.
Ew. They call each other “unintentional roleplay”??? That’s a little worrying. lollll. Not sure whether to laugh or cringe. I’ve been enormously excited for this one. A Sherlock retelling! Charlotte sounds a little like Princess Eleanor from The Royals, personality-wise, and it sounds interesting. Darling review, Aila! ❤
OMG PEACH NOOOO. :’D
I meant they call each other “Holmes” and “Watson,” which to me is like roleplay but it’s natural for them, ya know? Thus the “unintentional.” PLEASE DON’T THINK THAT. *laugh-cries*
Thanks so much though ❤ I hope you like it!
Let’s not get into my thoughts on this one. I’m so glad that you enjoyed it though, since this one is highly anticipated by everyone!
LMAO. I can totally see where you come from though! I just really liked how fun it was. 😀
I always love the dynamic between John and Sherlock, and I can’t wait to see how the characters in this book would potray that. Plus interesting crime cases is had to write so I kind of want to know how the author would pull that off. Great review!
Hehe thanks so much Tasya! And yup, the chemistry between Holmes and Watson was just smokin’. The crime case was definitely well-done in this one!